NOAH & PAW Leather Dog Collar Review — Medium, Dark Green

Intro

I’m The Pet Dude — a pet parent and gear nerd — and I spent time digging through the listing details and owner feedback on the NOAH & PAW Dog Collar (Medium, Dark Green) to see where this collar really lands. On paper this is a polished, oil-wax tanned leather collar with solid brass hardware and a classic buckle closure. It’s positioned as a premium-but-simple basic collar meant to balance softness and durability. In this review I break down fit, materials, everyday handling, safety, and the kinds of pets and households that will get the most mileage out of it.

What it is / first look

At a glance the NOAH & PAW collar is a leather basic collar built around a classic buckle-and-D-ring design. Key facts from the listing that shape first impressions:

• Material type listed as "Brass, Leather."
• Described as oil-wax tanned leather with handmade-quality craftsmanship and a stated thickness of 3.7 mm.
• Closure type listed as a buckle, specifically a solid brass buckle; the description also calls the hardware "heavy-duty" and "rust-resistant" and mentions a D-ring for leash attachment.
• Size shown in this listing: Medium — neck size range 14"–19" and an item length of 19 inches (the Medium size).
• Color (default) in this listing: Dark Green; other colors are listed in the product data.
• Item weight: 1.76 ounces; product dimensions are included in the listing.

The brand leans into a luxury aesthetic: oil-wax tanned leather that "grows richer with time," premium packaging, and a matching leash sold separately to create a coordinated set. The listing calls out a balance of softness and durability, and it lists a 10-year warranty—an uncommon long warranty promise for a collar and a notable callout in the product facts.

Colors and sizes

The listing explicitly lists these available colors:

• Dark Green
• Dark Blue
• Grey
• Camel

Available sizes show the usual range from Extra Small up through Large. The listing provides a size chart with neck ranges: Extra Small 9"–12", Small 11"–15", Medium 14"–19", Large 18"–24". The item in this listing is the Medium (14"–19").

In daily use

Rather than inventing my own wearing notes, I synthesized the hands-on themes that appear in the product notes and matched those to how this collar will behave in everyday life.

Fit and comfort (medium dogs / life stages)

The Medium size is listed to fit necks 14"–19" and the specific item shows an item length of 19 inches. Multiple notes tied to fit emphasize measuring the neck before ordering; the listing itself also urges buyers to measure. From the feedback patterns I reviewed, several owners found the medium to be true to size when they measured their dog’s neck as recommended. The collar is described repeatedly as soft — phrased in the listing as a balance of softness and durability and echoed in owner impressions calling the leather "very soft" and "soft compared to other leather collars." That softness makes it a congenial option for dogs across life stages (the listing states "All life stages"). One owner specifically used it on a senior dog and described it as comfortable.

Daily handling and hardware

Hardware on the listing is described as heavy-duty, rust-resistant metal with a solid brass buckle and a D-ring. People who handled the collar reported the brass hardware feels hefty but not overly heavy, and the buckle design is the classic buckle closure rather than a quick-release clip. That means putting it on is the standard threading-and-buckle process; one note mentioned it was a little difficult to slide the collar through during adjustment but ultimately did fit securely.

Style and presentation

The collar is squarely marketed as a stylish, refined collar: oil-wax leather, natural unisex colors, and premium packaging. Several notes praised the green and grey shades as particularly attractive against darker coats and flagged the packaging as "cute" and well-presented. If presentation matters to you — for gifting or a polished everyday look — that’s a clear win.

Indoor vs. outdoor performance

The listing claims the product was developed to stand up to everyday wear, but I also observed mixed signals in owner experience about ruggedness. Some owners expect years of use; others flagged that the material feels more velvety or soft than rugged leather and may be prone to damage in heavy outdoor use. If your dog spends a lot of time in wet, muddy, or brushy conditions, the listing doesn’t provide technical waterproofing claims, and owner feedback suggests caution for heavy outdoor use.

Materials & build quality

The listing gives us concrete material and construction details, which are useful when you care about build fidelity:

• Leather: Described specifically as premium oil-wax tanned leather. The product notes emphasize a 3.7 mm thickness developed to balance softness and durability.
• Hardware: Closure documented as a solid brass buckle; the description repeats that hardware is heavy-duty and rust-resistant and includes a D-ring for leash attachment.
• Craftsmanship: The listing frames the collars as handmade-quality, developed after months of refinement.
• Product care: The listing’s care instructions are "Hand Wash."
• Packaging: Included components explicitly list "Premium Packaging."
• Warranty: The listing gives a 10-year warranty description.

Those are solid signals for build intent: oil-wax tanning, a concrete thickness figure (3.7 mm), and brass hardware are all consistent elements for a leather collar aimed at blending aesthetic and day-to-day use. Owner impressions I reviewed call the leather "full grain but very soft" and praise the finish and color. A few owners, however, questioned long-term ruggedness for outdoor dogs; the listing’s language leans toward long-term, but I balance that with the mixed durability notes from hands-on feedback.

Safety considerations

Pet safety comes first, so here are the explicit safety-related points drawn from the listing and the owner feedback themes:

• Buckle & D-ring: The collar uses a solid brass buckle with a rust-resistant metal D-ring for leash attachment. That hardware is the primary safety anchor and is described as heavy-duty in the listing.
• Sizing & fit: The listing repeatedly advises measuring your dog’s neck to ensure the right size. Fit matters for escape risk and choking hazards; the listing provides neck ranges for all sizes (Extra Small 9"–12", Small 11"–15", Medium 14"–19", Large 18"–24").
• Material wear: While leather and brass are classic materials, several owners flagged that the leather can be softer/velvety-feeling and might be more prone to damage if used heavily outdoors. Damaged collars can present safety issues if stitching, leather, or hardware fail — the owner notes suggest exercising caution in high-abrasion settings.
• Tag attachment: Some owners reported using slide-on tags and noted the collar can be a tight fit to thread tags on; the listing does not provide explicit tag-attachment guidance beyond the presence of a D-ring. The listing does not specify any elastic keeper or secondary loop to lock down leftover length, and one owner mentioned excess leftover material that sticks out and can be annoying.
• Care instructions: The product care guidance in the listing is "Hand Wash." There are no technical claims about waterproofing or specific cleaning protocols beyond that.

Two actionable safety takeaways: measure carefully before buying, and if your dog is a heavy chewer, spends a lot of time in rough outdoor environments, or tends to get collars dirty and wet, make a plan for closer inspection and more frequent replacement — the listing’s materials are classic and attractive, but owner notes signal that rough use may shorten their lifespan.

Who this is for / who should skip

I try to match gear to real pets and use cases, so here’s how the NOAH & PAW Medium collar breaks down for different dogs and households, using the listing’s facts plus the hands-on themes I observed.

Good fit for

• Style-first owners who want a polished, oil-wax leather look for daily walks, photos, and a refined aesthetic. The listing emphasizes unisex, flattering color options and premium packaging.
• Owners of medium-breed dogs whose necks fall in the 14"–19" range: the Medium listing and sizing chart make this a logical pick when measured correctly. The listing also describes suitability across life stages ("All life stages").
• Owners who prefer traditional buckle collars and solid metal hardware over plastic quick-release clips — the brass buckle and D-ring are classic and durable when used as intended.
• Less active indoor dogs or house-oriented pets: owner notes specifically call out that the collar is perfect for indoor dogs and seniors who value softness and comfort.

Who should skip or be cautious

• Heavy chewers or extremely active outdoor dogs. While the listing claims a balance of softness and durability, the owner feedback that the material can be more velvety and potentially prone to damage in rough outdoor conditions suggests caution for high-abrasion use.
• Owners who want waterproof, technical collars. The listing does not claim waterproofing, and the care instructions list "Hand Wash" only.
• Shoppers who need an ultra-easy tag-sliding experience: one reported detail is that threading tags or excess collar through keepers can be tight and fiddly, and there can be leftover material that sticks out.

Verdict

NOAH & PAW’s Medium oil-wax leather collar is a well-styled, softly finished leather collar with solid brass hardware and a traditional buckle closure. The listing provides clear sizing guidance (Medium = 14"–19" neck), a stated leather thickness of 3.7 mm, and product care instructions of "Hand Wash." Packaging and finish are high on the brand’s list of selling points, and a 10-year warranty is called out in the product facts.

Where the collar shines: it’s soft, attractive, and built with classic materials (leather + brass). It’s a good match for medium-breed dogs that spend most of their time in domestic settings, owners who appreciate a refined look, and anyone who prefers a brass buckle and D-ring to plastic hardware.

Where to be cautious: there are mixed durability signals in owner feedback. Some reported the leather felt velvety and potentially vulnerable to heavy outdoor wear; others expected years of use. If your dog is a heavy chewer, spends a lot of time in mud or brush, or needs a collar that can be repeatedly soaked and left to dry, this collar may require more frequent checks and possible replacement sooner than a ruggedized, waterproof option.

Check before you buy

• Measure your dog’s neck. The listing provides exact neck ranges for each size; the Medium shown here fits 14"–19".
• Decide how the collar will be used. If your dog is mostly indoor or gently walked, this is stylistically strong; if your dog is a frequent swimmer/chewer, consider a more rugged alternative.
• Consider tags and keepers. The listing shows a D-ring for attachments, but threading slide-on tags may be tight per hands-on notes — plan for a tag carrier or check fit before finalizing.
• Pick a color and matching leash if desired. The collar comes in Dark Green, Dark Blue, Grey, and Camel; a matching Noah & Paw leather leash is sold separately if you want a coordinated set.
• Follow the listed care instructions. The listing specifies "Hand Wash" for product care.
• Remember the warranty. The listing includes a 10-year warranty description; check the seller’s warranty details on purchase for coverage specifics.

Overall, this collar is a strong choice if you want a soft, attractive leather collar with brass hardware and a classic buckle, and you factor in the mixed durability notes if your dog spends a lot of time outdoors or is a heavy chewer.