WOOF Pupsicle Treat Tray Mold Review

Intro — why I tried this mold

As someone who loves making my own dog snacks and keeps a steady rotation of enrichment toys, I picked up the WOOF Pupsicle Treat Tray Mold to make frozen refills for the Pupsicle toy. The idea is simple: pour a mix of wet food, yogurt, broth, peanut butter or other safe ingredients into a silicone tray, freeze, pop the frozen pieces into the Pupsicle toy, and hand your dog a long-lasting, cold treat.

The listing positions this as a reusable, dishwasher-safe silicone mold designed to make homemade treats for the Pupsicle system. The model I tested is the Large size (the product title includes a Large sizing tag for dogs 25–75lbs). The tray itself is silicone and listed as bisphenol-A (BPA) free, with item dimensions of 4.5 x 4.5 x 1.75 inches and an item weight of 1.6 ounces. In practice it makes four frozen discs per batch and is built to pop the pieces into the toy.

What it is — first look

The WOOF Pupsicle Treat Tray Mold is a small silicone molding tray intended to create four frozen "pupsicles" that fit the Pupsicle toy. It ships as a single-count component and is listed by the brand WOOF. The tray I handled came in the Yellow color called out on the product page.

Key things to know right away:

• Design: silicone tray with four cavities sized for the Pupsicle refill system.
• Materials: silicone, listed as BPA-free.
• Cleaning: the listing states it is dishwasher safe.
• Sizes available: the product is sold in multiple sizes (Small, Large, and X-Large are offered on the listing); the Large version is labeled for 25–75 lb dogs in the product title.
• Dimensions & weight: 4.5 x 4.5 x 1.75 inches, 1.6 ounces (as listed).

In daily use — hands-on testing

I approached this the same way I approach most simple silicone kitchen tools: test the fit, evaluate how easy it is to fill and unmold, check how it deals with the freezer, and see how the frozen pieces perform in the Pupsicle toy during play sessions.

Filling and freezing

The tray is straightforward to fill. The listing highlights that you can use wet food, broth, yogurt, peanut butter, and similar mix-ins. In my runs I tried thicker mixes (Greek-style yogurt blended with small bits of fruit and some dry kibble) and thinner mixes (broth and a spoon of peanut butter). The listing and long-term notes both warn that the more liquid the mix, the faster the pupsicle gets licked away in the toy. I found that to be true: runnier mixtures produced treats my dog polished off much faster, while thicker blends with kibble or oatmeal stretched the play time out.

The listing says it takes "in just a few hours" for the tray to create frozen treats; in my freezer it took several hours for fully solid pieces—enough that I wouldn't expect same-hour turnover. I recommend freezing them on a flat surface and not overfilling the cavities. Overfilling is an easy mistake: the internal notes note that if the liquid domes above the flat top it can prevent the frozen refill from seating properly in the Pupsicle toy and make the toy hard to close. The tray also expands slightly when frozen according to the owner experiences, so stop filling right at the flat top, not above it.

Unmolding and handling

Because the tray is silicone, the frozen treats pop out cleanly for the most part. The listing (and many hands-on accounts) praises the silicone for not holding onto sticky mixes. I found the treats released with a gentle flex and a little push from the back. A couple of times a very cold, denser mix stuck slightly and needed a short warm rinse to help release—still easier than trying to get frozen food out of a rigid plastic cavity.

One workflow that worked well for me: freeze on a flat tray, then after freezing pop the pieces out and store them in a quart-size zipper bag in the freezer. That allows you to make a small batch and keep extras ready to go.

How they perform in the Pupsicle toy

The whole point of the tray is to make refills for the Pupsicle toy, and in my testing the frozen pieces fit the toy as intended. Several hands-on notes emphasize that the tray creates frozen treats that fit perfectly in the holder and that pairing the tray with the toy is the intended way to use both. That means you get a consistent shape and size every time, which is convenient compared with trying to freeze a mixture directly inside the toy.

A practical tip from repeated use: mix thickness matters for enrichment. If you want a longer-occupying treat, add solids like kibble, oats, or crumbled dry treats to the mixture. Smoother, runnier fillings will give more immediate reward but shorter entertainment.

Cleaning

The listing states the tray is dishwasher safe. In my routine I usually wash it with hot water and dish soap or toss it on the top rack of the dishwasher for convenience. The silicone is forgiving and dries quickly. I also air-dry it between batches.

Materials & build quality

The tray is made of silicone and specifically listed as free of bisphenol-A (BPA), which is spelled out in the product specifications. Silicone is the right material for this kind of flexible tray—nothing sticks, and it handles freezer temperatures without becoming brittle.

• Fit & sizing
  • Large size is identified in the product title for dogs in the 25–75 lb range.
  • Other sizes (Small and X-Large) are offered on the listing.
  • The tray makes four frozen discs per batch.
• Finish & feel
  • Flexible silicone that pops treats out cleanly in most cases.
  • Some impressions say the tray can be a little floppy when filled, so freeze on a flat surface to avoid spills.
• Cleaning & maintenance
  • Dishwasher safe according to the listing; hand-washing with hot water and soap also works well.
  • Store popped treats in a zipper bag to keep extras ready.

Overall the build is solid for a silicone tray: it’s flexible but not so flimsy that it collapses during normal use if you handle it carefully. A few owners noted the tray felt "flimsy" when filled, so I treat it like a piece of bakeware: support it on a baking sheet when carrying it to the freezer.

Safety considerations

Safety first: the tray is silicone and listed as BPA-free, which is good for freeze-and-serve food work. The listing explicitly mentions feeding dog-safe items like wet food, broth, yogurt, and peanut butter; it’s up to you to choose ingredients that are safe for your dog’s size, age, and health. The product listing doesn't list ingredient restrictions or guidance, so consult a qualified professional for any diet or allergy questions.

• Choking and fit risks
  • Because the tray makes a specific size of frozen disc, double-check fit in your Pupsicle toy before giving it to your dog. Overfilling can create a dome that prevents the refill from seating properly in the toy, which can make it hard to close.
  • The Large mold is labeled for 25–75 lb dogs in the listing title; if your dog is smaller, choose a smaller tray or the Small size.
• Ingredient safety
  • Pick, dog-safe ingredients. The listing markets common options, but it does not list detailed ingredient safety guidance for each mix or a professional endorsement.
  • In one long-term usage note, a particular commercial "dental mix" sold by the company caused vomiting in one dog. I tested other mixes like plain Greek-style yogurt, pumpkin puree (not pie filling), peanut butter, and small amounts of fruit with no issues. That experience is a caution to check ingredient lists and watch how your dog reacts when you try a new mix.
• Cleaning & hygiene
  • The listing calls the tray dishwasher safe; regular cleaning after each use prevents lingering food smells and bacterial growth. I rinse and either hand-wash with hot soapy water or use the dishwasher.

Overall there are no active recall or toxic-material flags in the listing. The main safety signals are common-sense: avoid overfilling, choose dog-safe ingredients, and ensure the frozen refill seats properly in the toy.

Who this is for — and who should skip it

This is a narrowly focused product: it’s made for people who want to make frozen refills for the Pupsicle toy. If that’s your setup, this tray is a helpful convenience item. If you don’t own the Pupsicle toy, the tray may still be useful as a small silicone mold for frozen treats, but note it only makes four at a time and is sized for that system.

Great fit if you:

• Use the Pupsicle treat toy regularly and want consistent-sized refills without fuss.
• Prefer making DIY treats at home from simple ingredients (yogurt, peanut butter, pumpkin, wet food, broth, etc.).
• Value dishwasher-safe silicone for easy cleaning.
• Own a mid-size dog in the 25–75 lb range (Large tray is sold with that range in the title).

Skip or consider alternatives if you:

• Need to make dozens of refills at once — the tray makes only four per batch; mini muffin tins or multiple trays may produce more refills faster.
• Have a power chewer or a dog that quickly destroys hard frozen treats. The listing and notes emphasize licking-style play; very aggressive chewing isn't the intended use.
• Don’t own the Pupsicle toy and want a mold that makes many smaller frozen treats — some owners prefer mini muffin tins for volume.

Verdict — my take as The Pet Dude

The WOOF Pupsicle Treat Tray Mold is a tiny, focused convenience tool that does its job: the silicone tray makes four consistent frozen refills that fit the Pupsicle toy, it’s easy to clean, and it gives you control over what goes into your dog’s frozen treats. For people who already own the Pupsicle toy and want to DIY their refills, this tray quickly becomes one of those kitchen items you reach for without thinking.

It’s not for everyone. If you want to crank out lots of refills at once, the four-cavity layout slows you down compared with using mini muffin tins. A few owner notes describe the tray as a little floppy when filled, meaning you should freeze on a stable, flat surface to avoid spills. Also, be cautious with pre-mixed commercial blends—one reported experience of vomiting after using a company's dental mix is a sober reminder to read ingredient lists and observe how your dog reacts to a new treat.

Check before you buy — quick checklist

• Confirm you use (or plan to use) the Pupsicle toy — the tray is designed for that system.
• Pick the right size: the Large tray is labeled for 25–75 lb dogs in the product title; Small and X-Large are available on the listing.
• Plan for only four refills per batch — if you need more, either use multiple trays or consider mini muffin tins to increase yield.
• Don't overfill the cavities: fill to the flat top and avoid doming the liquid so the frozen piece will seat correctly in the toy.
• Freeze on a flat surface and handle the filled tray with a supporting baking sheet to prevent spills if the tray feels floppy.
• Stick to -safe ingredients and monitor your dog when trying a new mix; the company’s dental mix caused vomiting in one recorded instance.
• Use the dishwasher or hand-wash with hot, soapy water to clean between batches.

Overall, if you own the Pupsicle toy and want an easy, reusable way to make consistent frozen refills with ingredients you choose, this silicone tray is a useful, easy-to-clean tool. If you need high volume or a rigid tray that won't flex at all when filled, consider supplementing it with larger-capacity molds.